I’m not that good at primary and secondary kinetic isotope effects, so I thought I’d review and refresh. If you click on the I remember Clifford youtube link, you can study in style!
Chances are that you might want to review this stuff too, since I know my memory is spectacularly bad with physical organic chemistry.
Kinetic Isotope Effects (KIEs) are good indicators of the mechanism of a reaction. First we exchange a hydrogen for a deuterium in a compound. If the H/D bond is broken in the rate determining step, this is called a primary KIE. We compare the relative rates of reaction to establish a quantitative (numerical) basis for understanding how different the rate of reaction with hydrogen (k h) is with the rate of reaction with deuterium ( k d).
The upshot of all this is the C-D bond has a greater activation energy than the C-H bond. The C-D bond is stronger[2], with a lower zero-point energy (ZPE) than a C-H bond, however their differences in energy disappear at the transition state.
In short, it’s much easier to remove a H than a D, which explains why primary KIEs are usually above 2. The one in the illustration is probably about 5. If the primary KIE is relatively low (i.e. 2), then the transition state (TS) looks like either the product or reactant. If the primary KIE is high (i.e. 6), then the TS involves significant bonding between the hydrogen and both the old and new binding atoms.
Yeah that’s all the brain power I have tonight… more tomorrow!
[1] Also, I Remember Clifford and I’ll Remember April. oh zeh Jazz Muse ik!
[2] This is due to several factors. First, the vibrations associated with a C-D bond contribute less to the zero-point energy (ZPE) than the vibrations from a C-H bond, which makes a lower ZPE. (I don’t really understand this?) help




